A New York police sergeant shot and killed an emotionally disturbed naked 66-year-old woman who police say was wielding a pair of scissors and then a baseball bat.
The New York Post identified the officer as Hugh Barry and the woman who was killed asDeborah Danner.
Danner – who called herself a gem in the rough on Twitter and opined about police – was killed by police inside her own apartment bedroom in the Bronx on October 18, according to NBC New York. Danner was shot twice by the officer, said NBC New York.
Some have compared Danner’s shooting to that of Eleanor Bumpurs, 69, who was shot and killed by police in 1984 in her Bronx apartment. In the Bumpers shooting, the officer was called to her apartment for an eviction dispute and was charged with manslaughter, but was acquitted,said The New York Times.
Here’s what you need to know:
1. Danner Was Naked & Wielding a Pair of Scissors & Bat
At 6:15 p.m. on October 18, a uniformed sergeant, Barry, entered the woman’s apartment. “The sergeant encountered a 66 year-old female in a bedroom who was armed with a pair of scissors,” the NYPD says.
NBC New York said the woman was naked.
The official police account then says the sergeant “engaged the female in conversation and persuaded her to put down the scissors.”
The sergeant was able to engage the woman in dialogue and he was able to get the woman to drop the scissors
— NYPD NEWS (@NYPDnews) October 19, 2016
However, the incident didn’t end there.
She then grabbed a baseball bat. As the woman attempted to strike the sergeant he fired two shots at the woman from his service gun
— NYPD NEWS (@NYPDnews) October 19, 2016
.
“After putting down the scissors the female subject approached the sergeant and grabbed a baseball bat,” the NYPD says. “As she attempted to strike the sergeant he fired two shots from his service revolver striking her in the torso.”
2. Danner Had Schizophrenia & Wrote About Black Lives Matter on Twitter, Calling Herself a ‘Gem in the Rough’
Neighbor says Bronx woman shot by #NYPD Sgt was “very disturbed… I give cops the benefit of the doubt right now” pic.twitter.com/ULDvT4BueJ
— Tony Aiello (@AielloTV) October 19, 2016
The call came in for an emotionally disturbed person.
According to The NYPD, at approximately 6:06 p.m., police in the 43rd Precinct “responded to a 911 call for an Emotionally Disturbed Person at 630 Pugsley Avenue in the Bronx.” ABC7 said the caller told police the woman was armed with scissors in a hallway.
The Wall Street Journal reported that Raphelle Gundy, who lives in the building, “said she thought the woman had mental issues and neighbors often heard violent noises coming from her home.”
The neighbor said the woman became more disturbed when her mother died and told The Wall Street Journal that neighbors “would think somebody’s in there fighting her or attacking this lady. She’s hollering and screaming and talking like she’s going to hurt somebody.”
ABC7 said, “The cops were there practically once a month when she was off the meds.” Another neighbor told The New York Post, “She’s always screaming every day. Cursing and screaming. She’s just very angry when she’s not on her medication.”
On Twitter, Danner described herself as “a work in progress, I am a gem in the rough. I’ll smooth out soon..”
Some of her posts were political. She wrote, “With so much GUN VIOLENCE around us innocents, would someone PLEASE, PLEASE, PLEASE sponsor AMENDING THE 2ND AMENDMENT to reflect the 21s…”
Who’s getting old? Not me; between NOW and DEATH I have a lot to do…..
— Deborah Danner (@DeborahDanner01) October 5, 2016
She also wrote about police: “BEWARE: OFFICER(s) / PROVOCATEUR(s) + ANGER = RIOT(s)” and “WHAT A WORLD TO LIVE IN WHERE IT’S NECESSARY TO PUT POLICE IN JAIL…HAIL UTOPIA.” She also wrote: “Point of the Conversation: How’d U like to move about w/a TARGET on you because of the color of your skin? BLACK LIVES MATTER!
The wound, RACISM, continues to fester. PRAY for healing.
— Deborah Danner (@DeborahDanner01) July 8, 2016
And she tweeted: “Wherever this Life’s Journey leads and whatever happens, I GO DOWN FIGHTING!!!!”
3. A State Lawmaker Called the Shooting ‘Indefensible’ & Outrage Is Growing
Deborah Danner was her name. pic.twitter.com/GoDXuWBmYi
— Lisa Guido (@lisaguido) October 19, 2016
State Senator Ruben Diaz, Bronx Borough president, condemned the shooting as “indefensible” and an “outrage.”
My statement on tonight’s fatal #NYPD shooting in The #Bronx #BLM #blacklivesmatter https://t.co/8HxPyUFne6 pic.twitter.com/F0gk4yaL25
— Ruben Diaz Jr. (@rubendiazjr) October 19, 2016
“While I certainly understand the hard work that our police officers undertake to keep the streets of our city safe every single day, I also know what excessive force looks like,” Diaz said. “This elderly woman was known to the police department, yet the officer involved in this shooting failed to use discretion to either talk her down from her episode or, barring that, to use his stun gun.”
Diaz compared the shooting to the Bumpurs’ slaying and lamented that the city had learned little in three decades.
The more things change in NYC the more they remain the same #DeborahDanner #EleanorBumpers pic.twitter.com/ENQcqgIUfT
— Hakeem Jeffries (@RepJeffries) October 19, 2016
The mayor said he had been briefed on the shooting.
We’re determined to get to the bottom of what happened and won’t rest until we do. https://t.co/jPT1U4fX1H
— Bill de Blasio (@BilldeBlasio) October 19, 2016
The NYPD says the shooting is under investigation.
Bumpurs had a knife and threatened to throw lye, and her case is often listed in New York cases of police interaction with emotionally disturbed people.
4. The Officer Was Armed With a Taser but Didn’t Use It
#NYPD shoot and kill deranged bat-wielding woman in #Bronx, NYPD probing why police officer used gun over Taser. https://t.co/bWNOObYjG3 pic.twitter.com/EYzA0rAuIF
— WTOC Walter Ambrose (@ambrose03) October 19, 2016
The officer, Barry, was carrying a taser but didn’t use it, according to CBS New York. The New York Post said the officer has no disciplinary record.
One woman told The New York Daily News that she saw officers giving the woman CPR: “They were giving her CPR trying to bring her back but she was purple already. You could tell her color was changing and they were pumping her.”
The New York Daily News said Barry was placed on “modified duty,” an action sharply criticized by the police union, which called his actions justified. That means he loses his gun and shield until the investigation concludes, says the Daily News.
“Everyone agrees that this is a good shooting,” Ed Mullins, president of the NYPD Sergeants Benevolent Association, said to The Daily News.
5. A Neighbor Had Complained That Danner Was Acting in an ‘Irrational Manner,’ Police Say
The NYPD said in the news release that “the first officers arrived at the location within one minute and they were directed to the 7th floor, where a neighbor made a complaint regarding a female who was acting in an irrational manner.”
On Twitter, citizens questions why the call had to lead to shooting Danner.
Deborah Danner needed help.
— Ree (@mariamariaa7) October 19, 2016
#DeborahDanner had a history of mental illness & the police knew about it. smh
— ♛Tavia J ☥ (@mrs2lls) October 19, 2016
Officers encountered Danner in a bedroom, said CBS New York.
By Jessica McBride | Heavy